Car A
Mercedes-Benz CLA 250
The CLA 250 is a compact 5-seater that blends brisk acceleration with efficient fuel use and enough space for small families. It offers good value in its segment for commuting and road-trip duty.
Mercedes-Benz CLA 250
Suv · Gasoline
vs
BMW X1 sDrive18i
Suv · Gasoline · RWD
Car B
BMW X1 sDrive18i
The BMW X1 sDrive18i balances family-ready practicality with notably low fuel consumption for its class. It favors everyday usability and road-trip suitability over outright performance or heavy hauling.
Why compared
cross brandsame body typesame powertrainsame seatssimilar price
Usage fit
Family
68
/
65
City
48
/
49
Budget / value
62
/
48
Road trip
50
/
54
Performance
27
/
34
Cargo
28
/
38
Practical
50
/
44
Premium
46
/
45
Winter
36
/
44
Scores out of 100. Blue = Mercedes-Benz CLA 250 · Orange = BMW X1 sDrive18i
Specs side-by-side
Spec
Mercedes-Benz CLA 250
BMW X1 sDrive18i
Values are representative — confirm for your market and trim.
Pros & cons
Mercedes-Benz CLA 250
- Efficient for its class: 6.9 L/100 km helps keep fuel costs in check
- Brisk everyday performance with 0–100 km/h in 6.2 s (211 hp, 350 Nm)
- Seats 5 with a usable 370 L trunk for small‑family needs and weekend bags
- At a 36,000 price point, it represents good value in its segment
- 370 L trunk can feel tight if you regularly carry bulky cargo
- Not aimed at performance driving; enthusiasts may want sharper dynamics
- If you want the very lowest running costs, a hybrid or EV will be more efficient
- If the lowest purchase price is the priority, cheaper compact options exist
BMW X1 sDrive18i
- Efficient for its class at 6 L/100 km, easing fuel costs for commuting and family use
- Practical for growing families: five seats and a 540 L boot support school runs and weekend trips
- Ranks well for safety within its segment per our signals
- Rear-wheel drive dynamics with sufficient pace suit everyday driving
- You want brisk acceleration or sporty character; the 140 hp setup prioritizes efficiency over thrills
- You regularly carry very bulky loads; despite a useful 540 L boot, it’s not aimed at cargo-heavy use
- You need all-wheel-drive traction; this version is rear-wheel drive
- You’re chasing the absolute lowest price; better seen as good value in its segment than a bargain buy
Verdict
Pick Mercedes-Benz CLA 250 if…
Efficiency & everyday ease
Mercedes-Benz CLA 250 is the choice if fuel economy and city-friendly driving are your priority.
Pick BMW X1 sDrive18i if…
Performance & capability
BMW X1 sDrive18i is the choice if you want more power, speed, or all-weather capability.